When merchants think about launching subscriptions on Shopify, the first question is usually about the discount: "Should I offer 10% off or 20% off?" That question matters — and we cover it in our subscription pricing strategies guide — but there is an even more fundamental question that comes first.
Which pricing model should you use?
The model you choose shapes everything downstream: how customers perceive value, what they expect each delivery, how they manage their subscription, and how your operations need to work behind the scenes. A 15% subscribe-and-save discount and a $45 curated box are both "subscriptions," but they create completely different businesses.
This guide breaks down the four main subscription pricing models available on Shopify, explains when each one works best, and helps you decide which fits your store — or whether combining models is the right move.
Before diving into each model individually, here is a side-by-side overview of how they compare on the dimensions that matter most.
| Dimension | Subscribe & Save | Fixed-Price Box | Prepaid | Build-a-Box |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| How pricing works | Discount off regular price | Set price per box | Lump sum for multiple cycles | Price based on selections |
| Customer expectation | Same product, lower price | Curated surprise or themed selection | Commitment for savings or gifting | Choice and personalization |
| Best product types | Consumables, replenishment | Curated experiences, discovery | Gifts, seasonal, high-commitment | Variety-driven categories |
| Setup complexity | Low | Medium | Low–Medium | Medium–High |
| Typical AOV | Lower (single products) | Higher (bundled value) | Highest (prepaid lump sum) | Higher (multi-item bundles) |
| Retention driver | Convenience + savings | Anticipation + discovery | Upfront commitment | Control + variety |
Now let\'s look at each model in detail.
This is the most common subscription model on Shopify and the one most customers already understand. The customer buys a product they would purchase anyway, but at a recurring discount. The product stays the same each delivery. The value proposition is straightforward: convenience plus savings.
You set a product\'s regular one-time price, then offer a percentage discount (typically 10–20%) for customers who subscribe. The customer chooses a delivery interval — every 2 weeks, every month, every 6 weeks — and gets charged automatically on each cycle. They receive the same product each time unless they modify their subscription.
In Joy Subscriptions, you create a subscription plan, assign it to the products you want to offer on subscription, set your discount percentage, and choose which delivery intervals to offer. The subscribe-and-save widget appears on your product page, and customers can manage their subscription — skip, pause, change frequency, or cancel — through the self-service customer portal. Setup typically takes under 15 minutes.
A fixed-price subscription box is sold at a set price per delivery, regardless of which specific items are inside. The merchant curates the contents, and the value proposition is discovery, surprise, or themed experiences — not savings on a specific product.
You create a subscription product at a fixed price — say $39/month or $55/quarter. Each cycle, you curate the box contents. Customers do not choose individual items. They are buying your taste, your expertise, and the experience of receiving something selected for them. The box contents may change every cycle, which is part of the appeal.
Create a dedicated subscription product in Shopify (your box), then set up a subscription plan in Joy with a fixed price and your preferred billing interval. You can update the product description and images each cycle to reflect the current box theme. For deeper guidance on this model, see our curated box subscriptions guide.
Prepaid subscriptions ask the customer to pay upfront for multiple delivery cycles — typically 3, 6, or 12 months. The customer gets a discount for committing, and the merchant gets improved cash flow and a guaranteed retention period.
Instead of billing monthly, you charge the full amount at checkout. A 3-month prepaid coffee subscription at $14/bag might be priced at $39 (saving the customer $3 compared to three monthly orders). The customer receives deliveries on schedule, but the payment is already collected. When the prepaid term ends, the subscription either renews automatically or the customer is prompted to re-commit.
Joy Subscriptions supports prepaid plans out of the box. When creating a subscription plan, select the prepaid option, set the number of cycles (3, 6, or 12), and configure the pricing. You can offer a discount compared to the pay-as-you-go price to incentivize the commitment. The customer portal shows prepaid subscribers their remaining deliveries and upcoming renewal date.
Build-a-box puts the customer in control. Instead of receiving a pre-selected product or a merchant-curated box, the customer chooses which items go into their subscription bundle. Pricing is based on the selections they make — either a fixed price for a set number of items or a variable price based on what they pick.
You define the rules: how many items per box, which products are eligible, whether there is a minimum or maximum, and how pricing works (fixed bundle price or sum of individual items with a bundle discount). Customers build their box at checkout and can modify their selections before each delivery cycle.
Joy\'s build-a-box feature lets you define a product pool, set minimum and maximum item counts, and configure bundle pricing. Customers see an interactive selection interface on your product page. Between cycles, they can log into the customer portal to swap items before their next delivery ships. This model pairs well with email reminders prompting customers to refresh their selections.
If you are not sure which model fits your store, walk through these questions:
1. What type of product do you sell?
2. What does your customer value most?
3. What is your operational capacity?
4. What is your current churn pattern?
There is no universally "best" model. The best model is the one that matches your product, your customer\'s expectations, and your team\'s ability to execute consistently.
You do not have to pick just one. Many successful Shopify subscription stores run multiple models simultaneously, serving different customer segments with different subscription experiences.
Here are combinations that work well in practice:
Offer your standard monthly subscribe-and-save discount, but also give customers the option to prepay for 3 or 6 months at a deeper discount. This works especially well around holidays when gift subscriptions spike. The subscribe-and-save model handles your core recurring revenue while prepaid captures gift buyers and commitment-ready customers.
Let customers subscribe to individual products at a discount, or build a custom bundle at a bundle price. This is common in food, supplements, and beauty — some customers want their one favorite product on repeat, while others want to mix things up each month. Running both models lets each customer type find the subscription format that fits them.
Use a curated box to introduce customers to new products. When they find items they love, offer those items individually on a subscribe-and-save basis. The box becomes a discovery engine that feeds your replenishment subscriptions. This is a powerful combination for brands with a wide product catalog.
Offering too many options can overwhelm customers and complicate your operations. Start with one model, learn from your subscriber data, and add a second model only when you have a clear reason — not just because it is available. Each model you add multiplies your operational surface area: inventory planning, customer communication, portal management, and support complexity.
The four main models are subscribe-and-save (percentage-off recurring), fixed-price subscription box, prepaid subscriptions, and build-a-box (customizable subscriptions). Each serves different product types and customer expectations. Many successful stores combine two or more models to serve different customer segments.
Subscribe-and-save offers a discount on products customers already buy, delivered on a recurring schedule — the customer knows exactly what they are getting. A subscription box is a curated package, often with surprise or rotating items, sold at a fixed price. The value proposition is different: savings and convenience versus discovery and experience.
Prepaid subscriptions improve retention during the prepaid period because the customer has already committed financially. But the real question is whether they renew after the term ends. Prepaid works best when paired with a strong product experience that makes renewal feel like an obvious choice — not just a financial lock-in.
Yes. Many stores combine models effectively — for example, subscribe-and-save on individual products alongside a build-a-box option for customers who want variety. Joy Subscriptions supports all four models, so you can run them simultaneously without needing separate apps or workarounds.
Build-a-box and fixed-price subscription boxes typically generate the highest average order values because customers purchase multi-item bundles rather than single products. Prepaid subscriptions also produce higher upfront revenue. Subscribe-and-save tends to have lower per-order values but often delivers higher lifetime value in replenishment categories due to longer average subscription duration.
Choosing the right pricing model is one of the most important strategic decisions for your Shopify subscription business. If you have not already, read our subscription pricing strategies guide for the companion question: once you have chosen your model, how do you set the right price and discount within it? And if you are exploring specific product categories, our subscription business model guide covers the broader landscape of recurring revenue opportunities.
Joy Subscriptions supports all four models covered in this guide — subscribe-and-save, fixed-price boxes, prepaid plans, and build-a-box — with no monthly fee. The Starter plan charges 0% transaction fees for your first 6 months or first $1M in subscription revenue. If you are ready to launch or switch models, the setup takes minutes, not days.
The four main models are subscribe-and-save (percentage-off recurring), fixed-price subscription box, prepaid subscriptions, and build-a-box (customizable subscriptions). Each serves different product types and customer expectations. Many successful stores combine two or more models.
Subscribe-and-save offers a discount on products customers already buy, delivered on a recurring schedule. A subscription box is a curated package — often with surprise or rotating items — sold at a fixed price. Subscribe-and-save works best for replenishment products. Subscription boxes work best for discovery and gifting categories.
Prepaid subscriptions do improve retention during the prepaid period because customers have already committed financially. However, the real test is whether subscribers renew after the prepaid term ends. Prepaid works best when paired with a strong product experience that justifies the upfront commitment.
Yes. Many stores combine models — for example, subscribe-and-save on individual products plus a build-a-box option for customers who want variety. Joy Subscriptions supports all four models, so you can run them simultaneously without needing separate apps.
Build-a-box and fixed-price subscription boxes typically have the highest average order values because customers are purchasing bundles rather than single items. Prepaid subscriptions also generate higher upfront revenue. Subscribe-and-save tends to have lower per-order values but higher lifetime value due to longer retention in replenishment categories.
Join 5,000+ Shopify merchants using Joy Subscriptions. Free to install, no credit card required.
